. . .
I listened to a talk hosted by our special friend Marianne Motherby from Berlin this afternoon. The Right Honorable Sir Konrad Schiemann discussed his memoir “A Dual Perspective: The German in an English Judge.”
As a German orphan after WWII, he came to England to be raised by an uncle who left Germany before the war. Eventually, he rose to be a Lord Justice of Appeal in Britain and then a judge of the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg.
His story had potentially a Tom Stoppard “Leopoldstadt” element to it; his mother was Jewish, married to a Nazi naval officer. Yet, it seemed to make no difference to him. His mother survived the war seemingly without incident, only to commit suicide when learning belatedly of her husband’s death late in the war.
Harvard is experiencing these controversies after a consortium of over 30 student groups posted an open letter, saying that Israel was “entirely responsible” for the violence that ended up killing more than 1,400 people, most of them Israeli civilians. https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/18/us/harvard-students-israel-hamas-doxxing.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare
Some pro-Palestinian students have been harassed on or about campus and some major employers have withdrawn or threaten to withhold employment offers from members of the participating student organizations. This has come as a surprise to some of the best and brightest. Said one, "You kind of feel like you’re responsible,” obviously unaware of Newton's Third Law: For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction.
. . .
Thursday, October 19, 2023
Just as I urged you last week, I attended the talk by Steven Zipperstein about his forthcoming biography of Philip Roth. I am a sucker for erudition and Zipperstein thoroughly demonstrated it. I hope that you experienced it as well.Friday, October 20, 2023
After the book talk on Monday, I wrote to dear Marianne Motherby. “I enjoyed the session with Sir Konrad Schiemann, but ethnocentric me was bothered by his discounting the importance of his family’s Jewish background. What was fateful for so many others seemed of little importance to him." This morning, to my surprise, I received a letter from Sir Konrad, forwarded by Marianne. "I am deeply sorry that part of what I said about my family’s jewish background gave you the impression that the holocaust seemed of little importance to me." He left Germany when he was 7-years old. "When I came to England, every effort was made to distance me from Third Reich memories, as I explain in the book. So about such matters a discreet silence was kept." In Germany and England, his family was totally secular. "We were simply not brought up to think of ourselves as jews or jewish. It was not a category by which we divided mankind." This is a commendable universalist thought, neither subscribed to by philosemites nor antisemites.
